back to blog

Recap: Why Don’t Art Books Rate Review?

A brief summary in images and tweets.

Slide 1
Slide 2
Slide 3

Viewers of the panel discussion

Slide 4
Slide 5

On Saturday, September 29, the NY Art Book Fair presented a panel discussion moderated by Lesley A. Martin, publisher of The PhotoBook Review, that featured Sharon Gallagher, president and publisher of ARTBOOK | D.A.P, and Alberto Mobilio, co-editor of Bookforum.

@aperturefnd: Is there an increased or different form of literacy associated the art book that hasn’t yet reached the mainstream?#photobooks —LAM


color photograph

Viewers of the panel discussion

@aperturefnd: It’s a different thing to write review of a collection photos. How does one deal with visual material and objects, with non-textual content? —AM

The dearth of public commentary on photo- and art books and the scant attention paid to art writing can be disheartening. There’s a “Best American Writing on Mathematics” series but none for art? These two blindspots in mainstream cultural commentary were the topics under discussion on this panel.

color photograph

Leaders of the panel discussion

@aperturefnd: “you wouldn’t expect to read a poetry review without a quotation from a poem…it’s very hard to quote when the quote is visual” —SG
@aperturefnd: We must distinguish between reviews as marketing events vs. reviews as in-depth analysis and discussion, critique. #photobooks

Follow us on twitter (@aperturefnd).

Sign up for Aperture's weekly newsletter: